I am working on tin selenide orthorhombic structure, which is a polar material. A 4x12x12 k-grid adequately reproduces the electronic band structure between the QE and the Wannier90 codes.
When attempting to plot the electronic band structure with EPW-6.0, I use 4x12x12 for the coarse k-grid. For the fine k-grid, I use the band structure segments in the BZ. I found that by changing the q-grids, the wannier-interpolated electronic energies change. Using q-grids of 1x3x3 or 2x6x6 reproduces the correct electronic energies. But q-grids (both coarse and fine) of 4x6x6 lower the VBM by ~14meV. Attached are the band structure plots for two q-grids (https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B_CotT … sp=sharing). BTW, to reproduce the QE phonon band structure, I would need at least a 4x6x6 coarse q-grid.
Is there any reason why the size of the q-grids should affect the electronic energies? I printed some of the variables used in energy interpolation and found some differences between the rotation matrices (cufkk) between the two q-grids (2x6x6 and 4x6x6). Somehow, I think the electronic energies should be independent of the q-grids but I may be wrong.
Thank you,
Vahid
Vahid Askarpour
Department of Physics and Atmospheric Science
Dalhousie University,
Halifax, NS, Canada
You are correct, the interpolation of just the electronic eigenvalues should be independent of the q grid, i.e. of the phonons.
Did you run epw with exactly the same inputs, just different coarse q grids? and the same scf/nscf calculation before? Are the Wannier function centers and spreads printed in the epw output the same?
Yes, the scf.in, nscf.in and epw.in files are identical except for the q-grids and the save file for phonons. The wannier centres and spreads are the same. I even used the same number of cpus for the two runs. I would be happy to send you all the input and output files for the two q-grids if necessary.
Thank you for this tip. I know the code stops if the grids are not commensurate. It also stops if the coarse q-grid is larger than the k-grid. However, it did not complain in my case because 4x6x6 is commensurate with 4x12x12 and it is equal or smaller than 4x12x12, in a way.
So now I know that nk1=mnq1, nk2=mnq2 and nk3=m*nq3 with the integer m being 1,2, etc.