I’m just sending the frequencies from ph.x and EPW for a couple of additional q-pts (see below). I also compared phonon frequencies between EPW and ph.x for a much simpler system (cubic BN) where the interpolation works fine. I saw that although the frequencies are almost the same, they are not exactly the same – for example the frequency from ph.x is 1281.821 cm-1 while that from epw.out is 1281.7179 cm-1. I believe that’s numerical noise due to differences in diagonalization routines and also probably because EPW loses some precision in the dynamical matrix when reading from the file. Is it possible that the small errors in the dynamical matrix show exaggerated errors in the soft low-frequency modes of the perovskite (MAPbI3) crystal I’m studying here?
Just a thought and I may be completely wrong.
Best,
Sridhar
From ph.x
Diagonalizing the dynamical matrix
q = ( 0.000168668 -0.508381476 0.000098126 )
freq ( 1) = 0.505328 [THz] = 16.855917 [cm-1]
freq ( 2) = 0.516492 [THz] = 17.228326 [cm-1]
freq ( 3) = 0.572471 [THz] = 19.095591 [cm-1]
freq ( 4) = 0.831062 [THz] = 27.721242 [cm-1]
freq ( 5) = 0.927202 [THz] = 30.928130 [cm-1]
freq ( 6) = 1.038924 [THz] = 34.654783 [cm-1]
freq ( 7) = 1.114696 [THz] = 37.182252 [cm-1]
freq ( 8) = 1.343627 [THz] = 44.818564 [cm-1]
freq ( 9) = 1.628899 [THz] = 54.334208 [cm-1]
freq ( 10) = 1.827189 [THz] = 60.948471 [cm-1]
freq ( 11) = 2.040067 [THz] = 68.049312 [cm-1]
freq ( 12) = 2.253948 [THz] = 75.183617 [cm-1]
freq ( 13) = 2.421498 [THz] = 80.772490 [cm-1]
freq ( 14) = 2.579582 [THz] = 86.045580 [cm-1]
freq ( 15) = 2.856184 [THz] = 95.272047 [cm-1]
freq ( 16) = 3.231171 [THz] = 107.780277 [cm-1]
freq ( 17) = 4.075960 [THz] = 135.959391 [cm-1]
freq ( 18) = 4.520714 [THz] = 150.794772 [cm-1]
freq ( 19) = 9.672628 [THz] = 322.644131 [cm-1]
freq ( 20) = 26.845737 [THz] = 895.477407 [cm-1]
freq ( 21) = 27.753159 [THz] = 925.745740 [cm-1]
freq ( 22) = 29.190972 [THz] = 973.706011 [cm-1]
freq ( 23) = 36.952509 [THz] = 1232.603032 [cm-1]
freq ( 24) = 37.573356 [THz] = 1253.312241 [cm-1]
freq ( 25) = 42.203298 [THz] = 1407.750506 [cm-1]
freq ( 26) = 43.370977 [THz] = 1446.700056 [cm-1]
freq ( 27) = 43.527810 [THz] = 1451.931462 [cm-1]
freq ( 28) = 44.772502 [THz] = 1493.449913 [cm-1]
freq ( 29) = 47.102587 [THz] = 1571.173179 [cm-1]
freq ( 30) = 47.984900 [THz] = 1600.603961 [cm-1]
freq ( 31) = 89.904799 [THz] = 2998.901277 [cm-1]
freq ( 32) = 92.856884 [THz] = 3097.372258 [cm-1]
freq ( 33) = 92.969222 [THz] = 3101.119432 [cm-1]
freq ( 34) = 94.110756 [THz] = 3139.196913 [cm-1]
freq ( 35) = 94.881408 [THz] = 3164.903091 [cm-1]
freq ( 36) = 95.658657 [THz] = 3190.829350 [cm-1]
From EPW:
===================================================================
irreducible q point # 3
===================================================================
Symmetries of small group of q: 1
in addition sym. q -> -q+G:
Number of q in the star = 1
List of q in the star:
1 0.000168668 -0.508381476 0.000098126
Frequencies of the matrix for the current q in the star
13.00647 15.86393 18.27632 23.00463 28.85729 35.71825
37.39739 41.79450 51.01952 66.65791 75.35999 75.95179
79.98413 85.35635 97.55271 121.60487 128.31661 153.40686
327.11242 895.38935 926.34116 973.73406 1232.19449 1253.99304
1408.26002 1447.99955 1452.62126 1493.39151 1571.20749 1601.63069
2998.68882 3097.32073 3100.76643 3138.39476 3163.88902 3190.51484
From ph.x:
Diagonalizing the dynamical matrix
q = ( 0.004366201 -0.508271765 -0.502894410 )
freq ( 1) = 0.458527 [THz] = 15.294800 [cm-1]
freq ( 2) = 0.669768 [THz] = 22.341049 [cm-1]
freq ( 3) = 0.810661 [THz] = 27.040756 [cm-1]
freq ( 4) = 0.865478 [THz] = 28.869240 [cm-1]
freq ( 5) = 0.930919 [THz] = 31.052132 [cm-1]
freq ( 6) = 1.042329 [THz] = 34.768343 [cm-1]
freq ( 7) = 1.331478 [THz] = 44.413330 [cm-1]
freq ( 8) = 1.488400 [THz] = 49.647672 [cm-1]
freq ( 9) = 1.836231 [THz] = 61.250074 [cm-1]
freq ( 10) = 2.048938 [THz] = 68.345215 [cm-1]
freq ( 11) = 2.218131 [THz] = 73.988872 [cm-1]
freq ( 12) = 2.361016 [THz] = 78.755005 [cm-1]
freq ( 13) = 2.594236 [THz] = 86.534392 [cm-1]
freq ( 14) = 2.761214 [THz] = 92.104197 [cm-1]
freq ( 15) = 2.897797 [THz] = 96.660104 [cm-1]
freq ( 16) = 3.136809 [THz] = 104.632677 [cm-1]
freq ( 17) = 4.068208 [THz] = 135.700827 [cm-1]
freq ( 18) = 4.529847 [THz] = 151.099446 [cm-1]
freq ( 19) = 9.649192 [THz] = 321.862401 [cm-1]
freq ( 20) = 26.808176 [THz] = 894.224506 [cm-1]
freq ( 21) = 27.698874 [THz] = 923.934983 [cm-1]
freq ( 22) = 29.191629 [THz] = 973.727946 [cm-1]
freq ( 23) = 36.872169 [THz] = 1229.923166 [cm-1]
freq ( 24) = 37.578308 [THz] = 1253.477447 [cm-1]
freq ( 25) = 42.199265 [THz] = 1407.615971 [cm-1]
freq ( 26) = 43.430602 [THz] = 1448.688938 [cm-1]
freq ( 27) = 43.520914 [THz] = 1451.701421 [cm-1]
freq ( 28) = 44.796797 [THz] = 1494.260296 [cm-1]
freq ( 29) = 47.188819 [THz] = 1574.049563 [cm-1]
freq ( 30) = 47.981352 [THz] = 1600.485637 [cm-1]
freq ( 31) = 89.906171 [THz] = 2998.947047 [cm-1]
freq ( 32) = 92.861891 [THz] = 3097.539275 [cm-1]
freq ( 33) = 92.965562 [THz] = 3100.997372 [cm-1]
freq ( 34) = 94.160782 [THz] = 3140.865620 [cm-1]
freq ( 35) = 94.871608 [THz] = 3164.576219 [cm-1]
freq ( 36) = 95.540824 [THz] = 3186.898849 [cm-1]
From EPW:
===================================================================
irreducible q point # 4
===================================================================
Symmetries of small group of q: 1
in addition sym. q -> -q+G:
Number of q in the star = 1
List of q in the star:
1 0.004366201 -0.508271765 -0.502894410
Frequencies of the matrix for the current q in the star
18.24692 23.53322 26.61737 26.96061 33.68623 33.92830
42.50112 56.81356 64.48117 70.74882 75.17201 80.55632
84.96034 90.15693 101.04761 113.78587 129.34646 152.58117
326.35203 894.12728 924.53491 973.75548 1229.51312 1254.15680
1408.13077 1449.98991 1452.38397 1494.21109 1574.08044 1601.50976
2998.73594 3097.48779 3100.64262 3140.14908 3163.47862 3186.58516