I observe quite dramatic effect on the band gap correction with decreasing broadening,
Is this physical or artificial ?
In other words should the convergence of results be checked with decreasing broadenings such as 0.001, 0.0001, etc ?
In theory, the self-energy equation has to be solved self-consistently and the broadening is simply the imaginary part of the
electron-phonon self-energy.
Therefore some property diverge as the broadening goes to 0. However, in reality, the broadening is usually not zero.
my question is general, i like to know for el-ph affected valence and conduction band energy (gap renormalization)
should i set the broadening to a very (very ) small value, as you did in your JCP paper,
or not ?
I ask this because for some systems the correction to the valence or conduction band energy diverges, if you set the broadening to a very small value, causing a divergent gap correction.
On the other hand, for other systems the gap correction energy converges, even if the broadening is set to a very very small value.
So my question is how to do it correctly ? What is the consistent way ?
Should the broadening be set to a very small value or to a value at which the gap correction energy converges ?