A question about the variable "weight" in selfen_el.f90

Dear EPW Users,

I have extracted the individual self-energy contributions from a 20x20x20 q grid to a list of k points for the diamond example case with no fsthick set. For a random k point (0,0.1,0.45), I considered the contributions that 3 equivalent q’s make to the k point. The q points are
[code:2rwqblxu]
0.0000000 0.0000000 0.0500000
0.0000000 0.0000000 0.9500000
0.0000000 0.0500000 0.0000000
[/code:2rwqblxu]

Their six phonon energies are nearly the same
[code:2rwqblxu]
8.478513578340556E-004 8.690353269845230E-004 1.371788110062204E-003
9.805869334826509E-003 9.807700191526363E-003 9.976014814358882E-003

8.478507370144750E-004 8.690347206693874E-004 1.371787569949127E-003
9.805869388560562E-003 9.807700244964069E-003 9.976014888855781E-003

6.409839467282880E-004 6.409839747712517E-004 1.300855935719668E-003
9.823412612494933E-003 9.823412614324758E-003 9.985488830814850E-003
[/code:2rwqblxu]

But the weight variable calculated from
[code:2rwqblxu]
weight = pi * wqf(iq) * ( (wgkq+wgq)*w0g1 + (one-wgkq+wgq)*w0g2 )
[/code:2rwqblxu]

and their contributions to the k’s self energy (2nd column) are quite different as shown below:
[code:2rwqblxu]
2.840020921411006E-002 0.454447554214972
7.031015610841913E-004 0.163020527100226
4.599807289615457E-011 5.734701548147320E-010
[/code:2rwqblxu]

Since the three q’s have nearly the same energy while interacting with the same k electron, shouldn’t the weights be the same?

Thank you,

Vahid

Vahid Askarpour
Department of Physics and Atmospheric Science
Dalhousie University,
Halifax, NS, Canada

Hi,

I just would like to clarify that the weight I reported for the three q points were the last weights from the ik,imode,ibnd,jbnd loop. Otherwise, there are 96 weights in that loop for each ik and iq point which I did not report.

The self energies were calculated using the following matrix just before sigma_all’s definition:
[code:3rq73k00]
sigmai_tot(ibnd,ik+lower_bnd-1,iq)=sigmai_tot(ibnd,ik+lower_bnd-1,iq)+g2*weight
[/code:3rq73k00]

So the three self energies contributed by the three q’s were summed over the bands and modes.

Cheers,
Vahid

Hello Vahid,

You should check that the sum of the 96 weight is correctly 1 (or eventually 2).

If the point are truly random, the weight is likely to be 1.0/96 indeed.

Best,

Samuel

Hello Samuel,

Thank you for suggesting to check the sum of the weights. For the first q point and the k point I reported in my first post, I get these 96 weights which come from the 6 modes and 4 bands:
[code:8fgqbuez]
7.762864806541902E-004 1.900714716071483E-088 1.900714716071483E-088
1.900714716071483E-088 1.900714716071483E-088 1.021064846680064E-004
1.900714716071483E-088 1.900714716071483E-088 1.900714716071483E-088
1.900714716071483E-088 3.449724804790480E-003 3.624470068423790E-015
1.900714716071483E-088 1.900714716071483E-088 1.392555733007761E-013
1.162868088328380E-002 7.658697008806053E-004 1.855903177856707E-088
1.855903177856707E-088 1.855903177856707E-088 1.855903177856707E-088
9.988768852914349E-005 1.855903177856707E-088 1.855903177856707E-088
1.855903177856707E-088 1.855903177856707E-088 3.365972178129029E-003
3.608760629646159E-015 1.855903177856707E-088 1.855903177856707E-088
1.402167782315355E-013 1.142397687925616E-002 6.597723509642105E-004
1.205415093427186E-088 1.205415093427186E-088 1.205415093427186E-088
1.205415093427186E-088 6.851838511100885E-005 1.205415093427186E-088
1.205415093427186E-088 1.205415093427186E-088 1.205415093427186E-088
2.138126564063455E-003 3.884992399302110E-015 1.205415093427186E-088
1.205415093427186E-088 1.951103389053494E-013 8.807905983448494E-003
1.137642909376745E-002 4.219810241638788E-089 4.219810241638788E-089
4.219810241638788E-089 4.219810241638788E-089 2.757438543751118E-005
4.219810241638788E-089 4.219810241638788E-089 4.219810241638788E-089
4.219810241638788E-089 1.248181676748954E-004 1.651540243905585E-012
4.219810241638788E-089 4.219810241638788E-089 3.572659187442366E-009
2.806613303790095E-002 1.138197790051863E-002 4.219763605397296E-089
4.219763605397296E-089 4.219763605397296E-089 4.219763605397296E-089
2.756630180454055E-005 4.219763605397296E-089 4.219763605397296E-089
4.219763605397296E-089 4.219763605397296E-089 1.247326477863427E-004
1.653477104954179E-012 4.219763605397296E-089 4.219763605397296E-089
3.579755515211524E-009 2.806986024830347E-002 1.189778235600534E-002
4.215664645084622E-089 4.215664645084622E-089 4.215664645084622E-089
4.215664645084622E-089 2.681959948975107E-005 4.215664645084622E-089
4.215664645084622E-089 4.215664645084622E-089 4.215664645084622E-089
1.170590554948513E-004 1.840659337997957E-012 4.215664645084622E-089
4.215664645084622E-089 4.293959613693773E-009 2.840020921411006E-002
0.454447554214972
[/code:8fgqbuez]

They do not add up to 1 or 2. 0.4544 is the largest with the sum just over 0.56.

I obtained these weights by defining a new matrix wght as follows right after the definition of weight in my first post:
[code:8fgqbuez]
wght(ibnd,jbnd,imode,ik+lower_bnd-1,iq)=weight
[/code:8fgqbuez]

The q points are not random. The fine q grid is 20x20x20.

So now there are two issues:

  1. the weights do not add up to either 1 or 2.
  2. I was expecting the three (symmetrically equivalent) phonons to make almost equal contributions to the self-energy of the k point but they are vastly different as I reported in my first post. May be this is due to incorrect weight values.

Best,
Vahid

Dear Vahid

I think there was some slight confusion about the weights - they do not need to add up to 1 or 2 as they are the self-energy factors without the matrix element.
I understand that the q points you considered are equivalent, but I suppose the k+q points are not, so the eigenenergies at k+q will not be the same (hence the ‘weight’ quantity will be different).

Best
Carla

Dear Carla,

Thank you for the clarification. I was under the impression that symmetrically equivalent q phonons will interact with a k electron and result in symmetrically equivalent k+q states which naturally have identical energies based on energy conservation. I guess I was wrong.

Best wishes,

Vahid